ODGers,

I would appreciate any suggestions on teaching in this regard:

In the next couple of weeks, I will cover defenses to intentional torts with my U.S. 1Ls in Torts I.  The social, economic, and political climate being what it is in the United States, discussion of the defenses of self/others/property centers on castle doctrine and "stand your ground" (SYG) laws.

I have never been satisfied with my coverage of this "sub-subject."  I provide my students with sample state statutory language regarding SYG and civil proceedings (from Cal., Fla., Mass., and R.I.; happy to share the handout with anyone).  But there is a dearth of reported case law, or any other material, on these statutes.  Typically they are cited only collaterally, in criminal proceedings or in claims alleging third-party negligence.  The ugly encounters that might tend to yield civil litigation seem to peter out with the criminal dispositions--or at least the media coverage does.

My colleagues teaching criminal law spend a great deal of time on the criminal side of SYG, so I do not wish to duplicate their efforts, nor waste my class time with speculative analogy.  I would welcome any suggestions for material to stimulate or inform class discussion on this subject, focusing on the CIVIL side of castle/SYG--whether primary or secondary legal materials, or content from popular culture, especially audiovisual aids.  Comparative perspectives would be welcome as well.

Probably best to email me off list, unless you're itching to share with the group.

Sincere thanks for your consideration,
rick

Richard J. Peltz-Steele