From: Norman Siebrasse <norman.siebrasse@gmail.com>

Sent: Thursday 27 March 2025 11:52

To: obligations

Subject: Covid duty of care decision from Ontario on Canlii?

In  Hartman v. Attorney General of Canada et al., 2025 ONSC 1831 Antoniani J of the Ontario SCJ dismissed a liability claim by the family of Sean Hartman, an Ontario high schooler who died weeks after taking a Covid shot, holding that there was no private law duty of care. The decision was up briefly on Canlii yesterday - I read about it in Blacklock's, found it in Canlii and skimmed it, which is all to say I am sure it was really there. I then sent the link to a colleague with more of an interest in these matters. A couple of hours later the link was broken and the decision had been taken down. Did anyone download a copy before it got taken down? The case is called Hartman v some gov't body., probably the Ontario Dept of Health. (Or if it is still there and I am just really bad with Canlii, please let me know.)

Norman

--

Norman Siebrasse
Professor of Law
University of New Brunswick
Sufficient Description.com